Ruth bader ginsburg dissent in hobby lobby business insider. Ruth bader ginsburgs hobby lobby dissent is the best. The defeat of the contraceptive mandate in hobby lobby. Burwell v hobby lobby the wisdom of justice ginsburg. The divided courts 54 decision included a dramatic dissent from. In this wellchosen sentence that opens her dissenting opinion in hobby lobby, justice ginsburg explains how the majority decision, which authorizes business corporations to deny contraceptive care to millions of women employees, also generally rewrites american law to furnish corporations an allpurpose excuse for not complying with public laws. Justice ginsburg on gay marriage, hobby lobby, and nervous liberals. Justice ginsburgs dissent in hobby lobby purports to offer three independent grounds for ruling against hobby lobby.
Supreme court justice ruth bader ginsburgs fierce 35page dissent in burwell v. Read justice ginsburgs passionate 35page dissent of hobby lobby decision the divided courts 54 decision included a dramatic dissent from justice. Ginsburg was appointed by president bill clinton and took the oath of office on august 10, 1993. Read justice ginsburgs passionate 35page dissent of hobby lobby decision. This report analyzes the courts decision in hobby lobby, including arguments made between the. Ruth bader ginsburgs hobby lobby dissent goes viral with. The second woman to serve on the supreme court, she became an articulate representative of liberal perspectives on the court and eventually the leader of the courts minority liberal bloc. After brilliant hobby lobby dissent, time to let obama appoint successor. Conservative pundits and pols celebrate hobby lobby decision. Justice ginsburgs hobby lobby dissent has little basis in.
Justice ruth bader ginsburg, writing in dissent, says that corporations dont exercise religion. Did ginsburg move kennedy to narrow alitos hobby lobby. Subscribe and get breaking news, commentary, and opinions on law firms, lawyers, law schools, lawsuits, judges, and more. It seems unlikely, however, that both the house and senate would pass such a bill, especially in a congressional election year, and bills introduced in response to hobby lobby have already hit snags. Some, including justice ginsburg in her dissent, have argued that the decision has farreaching consequences and opens up the floodgates for. Alitos hobby lobby argument is stronger than ginsburg. A supreme court of nine women appointed by president george w.
Here are the highlights of justice ginsburgs fiery hobby. A sampling of court actions since hobby lobby suggests that ginsburg has the better of the argument. This focus is not intended to deny or disparage the importance of reproductive rights. Ginsbergs scathing dissent in hobby lobby case says faith. Thats ruth bader ginsburg, in the 35page dissent she wrote against the supreme courts decision in burwell v. As a faithful catholic with moral objections to forced christian complicity in both abortion and contraception, i had many reasons to rejoice in the supreme courts majority decision in burwell vs. Ruth ginsburg rejects the supreme courts opinion that hobby lobby is about contraceptives only. Apmatt sayles here are the highlights of justice ginsburgs fiery hobby lobby dissent the iconic member of the supreme courts liberal wing argues the majority has ventured into a minefield. Ginsburgs hobby lobby dissent, in emo musical form the. Supreme court nomination hearings from pbs newshour and emk institute duration. Ruth bader ginsburg brilliantly calls out the hobby lobby. Hobby lobby stores supreme court of the united states. Why ginsburgs hobby lobby dissent might backfire msnbc.
Where it is feasible, a syllabus headnote will be released, as is being done in connection with. She is the second female justice after sandra day oconnor of four to be confirmed to the court along with. Justice ruth bader ginsburgs dissent, she argued that the court had lowered the bar on what qualifies as a. A brilliant hobby lobby dissent reinforces iconic status. Jonathan mann grabbed his guitar and beautifully captured a passage from justice ruth ginsburgs 35page dissent of the recent hobby lobby decision. Lobby, and especially in justice ginsburgs dissent, other factors were. The footnote on page 2 of the burwell v hobby lobby dissent is a really big deal as far as im concerned. Hobby lobby ruling criticized by supreme court justice. The recent hobby lobby ruling by the supreme court was criticized by justice ruth bader ginsburg in a scathing dissent that she wrote after the ruling. Two premises in the majoritys argument were especially troubling. I argue in this comment that despite the emphasis on that subject in hobby lobby, and especially in justice ginsburgs dissent, other factors were at work in contributing to the degree of public attention and disagreement that accompanied this case. March 15, 1933 is an american lawyer and jurist who is an associate justice of the u.
Justice ginsburgs dissent in this weeks hobby lobby case has been receiving a considerable amount of attention from all quarters, and adulation from the left. Rbg has always been a hero in my eyes, but it was only in my deep research for this piece that i discovered just how hard the icon worked to earn her spot in history. Read ruth bader ginsburgs dissent in hobby lobby case e. The chorus about geezers, as you might expect, is an invention by mann. The supreme courts hobby lobby case basically turned into a heated hesaid, shesaid between justices samuel alito and ruth bader ginsburg. A judge committed to granting a religious exemption to the law would be able to find a way to use the hobby lobby opinion to justify doing so, even without ginsburgs dissent. On monday, justice ruth bader ginsburg penned a blistering dissent to the supreme courts 54 ruling that the government cant require certain employers to provide insurance coverage for. Asked if the five justices revealed a blind spot in their decision, ginsburg said yes. The exemption sought by hobby lobby and conestoga woulddeny legions of women who do not hold their. Concurrence, kennedy kennedy concurrence pdf dissent, ginsburg ginsburg dissent pdf dissent, kagan kagan dissent pdf note. In an interview with katie couric on yahoo news, the justice.
Read justice ginsburgs passionate 35page dissent of. Kennedy institute for the united states senate 202,871 views 10. I would have to say no, the 81yearold justice replied. Hobby lobby dissent lyrics justice ginsburg, with whom justice sotomayor joins, and with whom justice breyer and justice kagan join. The 8 best lines from ginsburgs dissent on the hobby. The limits to how the supreme court tried to limit its. It suggests a state of deep contestation around one of the key markers of the churchstate settlement2. The dark side of the cult of ruth bader ginsburg the nation. In an opinion for a 54 majority written by justice samuel a.
Ginsburg slams decision of startling breadth in hobby lobby dissent. Read justice ginsburgs passionate 35page dissent of hobby. Ron edmondsap supreme court justice ruth bader ginsburg wrote a blistering dissent opposing the conservative majoritys decision to let small, forprofit companies refuse to pay for health. Its written by the majority, and states that with regards to the alternative that churches and notforprofit religious organizations currently have to let the insurer or thirdparty administrator pay for the contraceptives, in.
Couric asked ginsburg of the 54 hobby lobby ruling, which cleared the way for employers to deny insurance coverage of contraceptives to female workers on religious grounds. Unfortunately, the courts reasoning was not one of them. American religious liberty is in a state of flux and uncertainty. Hobby lobby includes two extended analyses that ultimately read as dicta, because the majority opinion refuses to address the issueand they are both issues from which justice kennedys concurring opinion appears to distance itself. Each time ginsburg issued a dissent, social media lit up with memes of her nowiconic beaded jabot and a cocked crown under the sobriquet notorious rbg. How justice ginsburgs hobby lobby dissent helps shape the.
By tierney sneed, staff writer june 30, 2014 by tierney sneed, staff writer june 30, 2014, at 8. Though its unlikely courts will revisit racial discrimination, if ginsburg is right and businesses can get exemptions from providing services to certain minority groups, hobby lobby could create. The chief justice acknowledges that provisions of floridas election code may well admit of more than one interpretation. The best parts of ruth bader ginsburgs scathing 35page dissent in hobby lobby birth control case by by jenna mullins tue. Further, justice kennedys concurring opinion appears to be a direct response to justice ginsburgs dissent.
Ruth bader ginsburgs 35page dissent in the hobby lobby case has become the blueprint for how liberals talk about the supreme courts decision to allow familyowned and closely held. Here are seven more key quotes from ginsburgs dissent in burwell v. In its hobby lobby decision, the supreme court ruled that closely held. Patient protection and affordable care act religious freedom restoration act u.
1159 1645 1139 927 301 1206 916 511 151 1399 1476 1392 523 1606 1298 55 572 751 923 349 522 1630 274 91 1474 1474 673 819 1144 1314 381 156